As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Some links on this site are affiliate links at no extra cost to you. Our recommendations are based on thorough research and editorial judgment.

eco friendly cat litter options

10 Best Cat Litter Alternatives You Need to Try for a Greener Home

If you’re looking for sustainable cat litter alternatives, consider options like sWheat Scoop Natural Wheat Litter (25 lbs) or Dr. Elseys Ultra UnScented Clumping Clay Litter (40 lbs) for effective clumping. Honey Care All-Absorb Pellets (3.5 lbs) and pidan Tofu Litter (5.3 lbs) offer excellent odor control. Fresh News Recycled Paper Litter (12 lbs) and Nature’s Miracle Premium Clumping Corn Cob Litter (10 lbs) enhance moisture-locking, while Sustainably Yours Cat Litter (10 lbs) guarantees eco-friendliness. Explore your options further for best choices.

Key Takeaways

  • Explore eco-friendly options like sWheat Scoop, made from wheat, for a sustainable and natural cat litter choice.
  • Consider Feline Pine Platinum, utilizing pine shavings for excellent odor control and minimal environmental impact.
  • Try Nature’s Miracle Premium Clumping Corn Cob Litter, which effectively neutralizes odors with a bio-enzymatic formula from real corn.
  • Fresh News Recycled Paper Cat Litter offers three times the absorbency of clay, all while being 100% recyclable.
  • Transition to dust-free litters like Dr. Elseys Ultra UnScented or Pidan Tofu for safer options for pets with respiratory issues.

sWheat Scoop Natural Wheat Multi-Cat Litter (25 Pound Bag)

sWheat Scoop Natural Wheat Multi-Cat Litter, Superior Clumping with Odor Neutralizing Enzymes...
  • sWheat Scoop Natural Wheat Multi-Cat Litter: Super absorbent, natural wheat litter designed for multi-cat and multi-litter box households
  • Superior Odor Control: Powerful natural odor neutralizing enzymes trap odors on contact and neutralize urine and ammonia odors quickly to help eliminate smelly pet odors
  • Natural: sWheat Scoop eliminates odors using natural, domestically sourced wheat with no added dyes, perfumes, or chemicals; naturally lightweight, 99.5% dust free and...

sWheat Scoop Natural Wheat Multi-Cat Litter is an ideal choice for cat owners who prioritize both effective waste management and ecological sustainability. This 25-pound bag of litter features superior clumping, facilitating easier cleanups and minimizing mess in your home. Made from domestically sourced wheat, it’s free from harmful dyes, perfumes, and chemicals, ensuring a safe environment for both your pets and family members. The natural enzymes in the litter effectively eliminate urine and ammonia odors, promoting a fresher living space. Additionally, with its 99.5% dust-free composition, you’ll reduce health risks associated with respiratory issues, making it a reliable option for multi-cat households.

Best For: Cat owners looking for an eco-friendly, effective, and safe litter option for their multi-cat households.

Pros:

  • Excellent clumping ability for easier cleanups and reduced mess.
  • Natural enzymes effectively control odors from urine and ammonia.
  • Biodegradable and flushable composition, promoting sustainability.

Cons:

  • Some users report tracking and messiness.
  • Higher price point compared to traditional clay litters.
  • Mixed experiences with the effectiveness of clumping and dust control.

Dr. Elseys Ultra UnScented Clumping Clay Cat Litter 40 lb. Bag

Dr. Elsey's Ultra UnScented Clumping Clay Cat Litter 40 lb. Bag
  • PREMIUM QUALITY: A combination of premium texture and granule size made with 100% bentonite clay for maximum clumping creates litter particles that are just the right...
  • LOW DUST: Ideal for cats and owners who suffer from allergies with a 99.9% dust-free and hypoallergenic litter formulation.
  • HARD CLUMPING: Hard clumping medium grain clay helps prevent moisture from reaching the bottom of the tray and forms hard clumps that won't break down, making it easier...

For cat owners seeking a reliable and efficient litter solution, Dr. Elseys Ultra UnScented Clumping Clay Cat Litter comes in a 40 lb. bag, providing excellent value. This product is crafted from 100% bentonite clay, optimizing clumping, while its unique granule size minimizes dust to 99.9%, making it hypoallergenic for sensitive pets. Maintain your litter box by filling it with 3-4 inches of litter, scooping daily, and replacing it entirely each month. Be sure to dispose of used litter in the trash and wash your hands after handling to maintain hygiene and prevent unwanted contact with sensitive individuals.

Best For: Cat owners seeking a high-quality, hypoallergenic litter that offers excellent clumping and odor control for single or multi-cat households.

Pros:

  • Premium quality with solid clumping that is easy to scoop.
  • 99.9% dust-free formulation, ideal for allergy sufferers.
  • Unique granule design minimizes litter tracking outside the box.

Cons:

  • Some users report slight tracking of litter outside the box.
  • A few reviews mention residual dust when pouring the litter.
  • May require more frequent refills in households with multiple cats.

Honey Care All-Absorb Cat Litter Pellets, 3.5 Lbs Pack

Honey Care All-Absorb Cat Litter Pellets, Zeolite, Long-Lasting Odor Control Non-climping Litter...
  • Long-lasting superior odor control
  • Made of Zeolite mineral, a natural odor eliminator
  • 99.9% dust free

Honey Care All-Absorb Cat Litter Pellets, with its zeolite mineral formulation, offers exceptional benefits for pet owners seeking effective odor control and a cleaner living environment. Weighing 3.5 lbs, these light yellow pellets exhibit superior performance in dehydrating waste and blocking ammonia odors, ensuring long-lasting freshness. To use, pour the pellets into your litter box, scoop out solid waste daily, and replenish as necessary. Replacing the entire contents monthly optimizes results. With 99.9% dust-free composition, this product also minimizes litter tracking, promoting cleaner air. For best results, integrate Honey Care’s pads and consider appropriate litter boxes to further enhance odor management.

Best For: Pet owners looking for effective odor control and low-dust cat litter options.

Pros:

  • Superior odor control with natural zeolite to block ammonia and dehydrate waste.
  • 99.9% dust-free formula ensures cleaner air and minimizes respiratory irritations.
  • Designed to reduce tracking, helping maintain a neat environment around the litter box.

Cons:

  • May not be suitable for all cats; individual preferences can vary widely.
  • Some users reported issues with odor control, especially with certain cats.
  • Tracking problems may still occur with use, depending on the cat’s behavior.

pidan Tofu Cat Litter (5.3lb)

pidan Tofu Cat Litter Clumping,Flushable,Ultra Absorbent and Fast Drying, 100% Natural Ingredients...
  • 【100% Natural ingredients】Selected Quality Pea Dregs,Sponge-Like Water Absorption Performance.Faster Clumping and Lower Possibility of Touching a Cat Litter Box...
  • 【100% Dust Free 】Because it is made of 100% doufu, without any dust containing ingredients, it is really 100% dust-free.Ensuring a pristine environment and promoting...
  • 【Less Tracking】pidan tofu cat litter, with its elongated design, is less prone to rolling compared to mineral-based cat litter. Its lower density also helps reduce...

Pidan Tofu Cat Litter (5.3lb) is an excellent choice for pet owners looking for a natural, eco-friendly alternative that prioritizes both health and performance. Made from 100% natural quality pea dregs, this litter features clumping, flushable, and ultra-absorbent properties, ensuring efficient waste disposal. Its solubility allows you to dispose of it in toilets seamlessly. With a 100% dust-free composition, it minimizes respiratory issues for sensitive cats. Expect easy maintenance; you can clean three litter boxes in under five minutes. The unique particle mix reduces scattering, while effective odor control requires regular scooping to prevent unpleasant smells.

Best For: Pet owners looking for a natural, eco-friendly, and hypoallergenic litter solution for their cats, especially those with respiratory sensitivities.

Pros:

  • 100% natural ingredients with no harmful additives, making it safe for cats and the environment.
  • Clumping and flushable properties make maintenance easy and convenient for pet owners.
  • Dust-free formula helps reduce respiratory issues in sensitive cats.

Cons:

  • Higher price point may be a concern for budget-conscious consumers.
  • Odor control can be ineffective if not scooped regularly, leading to unpleasant smells.
  • Limited availability in certain regions, causing potential accessibility issues.

Fresh News Recycled Paper Cat Litter (12 Pound)

Fresh News Recycled Paper Original Pellet Cat Litter, 12 Pound, Non-Clumping, Unscented, Made in USA
  • Cat Litter: No more lingering pet smell; Fresh News Recycled Paper Litter is non clumping, has almost three times more absorbent strength than clay, and our soft & dust...
  • Odor Control: Keep your pet's habitat fresh and smell free! The moisture-locking pellets with baking soda and outstanding odor control work together to help neutralize...
  • 100% Recycled paper: Made with 100% post consumer paper from recycling centers, it is safe for all animals; This litter is also biodegradable when composted, so you can...

Fresh News Recycled Paper Cat Litter (12 Pound) is an exceptional choice for pet owners seeking a litter that prioritizes both environmental sustainability and the health of sensitive animals. Composed entirely of 100% post-consumer recycled paper, this non-clumping litter offers an absorbent strength three times greater than traditional clay. Its moisture-locking pellets, enhanced with baking soda, effectively control odors while remaining over 99% dust-free, making it suitable for cats with allergies. Regular scooping is essential for maintenance; consider using biodegradable puppy pee pads for easier cleanup. The durability of this product reduces the frequency of refills, ultimately providing cost-effectiveness.

Best For: Pet owners seeking an eco-friendly cat litter option that is gentle on sensitive paws and effective in odor control.

Pros:

  • Provides superior absorbency, three times greater than clay litter.
  • Over 99% dust-free and non-allergenic, ideal for cats with allergies or sensitivities.
  • Biodegradable and compostable, supporting sustainable waste management.

Cons:

  • Non-clumping nature may require more frequent maintenance and scooping.
  • Some users may prefer the texture of traditional clay litters for better tracking.
  • Initial cost may be higher than standard clay litters, despite cost-effectiveness over time.

ökocat Original Wood Clumping Cat Litter (13.2 pounds)

ökocat Original Wood Clumping Cat Litter, Unscented, 13.2 pounds - Natural Ingredients, Stops Odor...
  • NATURAL CAT LITTER: Our next-generation, plant-based, premium clumping cat litter is relentless at controlling odors while being exceptionally absorbent and naturally...
  • EXCEPTIONAL ODOR CONTROL: Wood fiber naturally prevents enzymes from bonding with liquid and waste to stop the creation of ammonia and odor
  • CLUMPING LITTER: Precision cut wood fiber absorbs liquid on contact, forming solid, easy-to-scoop clumps that make cleaning the litter box quick and easy

For those seeking a sustainable and effective solution for their feline’s bathroom needs, ökotac Original Wood Clumping Cat Litter (13.2 pounds) stands out as an excellent choice. This unscented litter, made from natural, plant-based ingredients, provides exceptional odor control by preventing enzyme bonding with liquids, thereby stopping ammonia formation. Its precision-cut wood fibers absorb liquid on contact, forming solid, easy-to-scoop clumps that make cleaning straightforward. The 99% dust-free formula guarantees healthier surroundings by reducing airborne particles during handling. Additionally, it contains no artificial fragrances or harmful chemicals, making it biodegradable and environmentally friendly, contrasting sharply with traditional clay litters.

Best For: Pet owners looking for a sustainable, effective, and natural cat litter option for their feline companions.

Pros:

  • Exceptional odor control by preventing enzyme bonding with liquids.
  • Solid clumping capability for easy cleaning and maintenance.
  • 99% dust-free formula for a cleaner and healthier environment.

Cons:

  • May not be as widely available as traditional clay litters.
  • Some cats may require time to adjust to the texture and feel.
  • Potentially higher cost compared to standard cat litter options.

Feline Pine Platinum Non-Clumping Cat Litter, Feline Pine Cat Litter 18lb

Feline Pine Platinum Non-Clumping Cat Litter, Feline Pine Cat Litter 18lb
  • LIGHTWEIGHT CAT LITTER so changing and refilling the cat litter box is fast and easy. That’s easy because this absorbent non-clumping kitty litter is natural and less...
  • HIGHLY ABSORBENT PINE LOCKS AWAY ODORS: Feline Pine cat litter is a lightweight non-clumping cat litter that directly binds to odors like thousands of tiny sponges to...
  • A NATURAL CAT LITTER CHOICE. No new trees are cut down to make the pine shavings in Feline Pine Platinum Natural Pine Non-Clumping Litter. This unscented cat litter comes...

Feline Pine Platinum Non-Clumping Cat Litter, designed for environmentally conscious pet owners, utilizes natural pine shavings to provide a sustainable and effective solution for odor control in your cat’s litter box. This 18-pound litter is made from kiln-dried pine shavings, which guarantees no new trees are cut down, contributing to environmental sustainability. The lightweight composition, less than half the weight of clay, minimizes dust during use, creating a cleaner environment. For maximum performance, fill the litter box with at least 3 inches of litter, scoop solid waste daily, and replace the litter when it primarily consists of sawdust.

Best For: Environmentally conscious cat owners looking for a natural, effective litter solution.

Pros:

  • Lightweight composition makes it easy to handle and reduces dust clouds during use.
  • Made from natural pine, providing excellent odor control and sustainability.
  • Cat-friendly with gentle pellets that are comfortable on paws.

Cons:

  • Some users report that urine absorption may not be as effective as clumping litters.
  • Cats may require a gradual transition from traditional clay litter to pine.
  • Replacing litter can be less convenient than clumping options, as waste must be scooped daily.

Nature’s Miracle Premium Clumping Corn Cob Litter (10 Pounds)

Sale
Nature’s Miracle Premium Clumping Corn Cob Litter, 10 Pounds, Made With Real Corn Cob For...
  • NATURAL CORN COB: Made with natural (heat-processed) corn cob for a powerful, fast-clumping litter – 99.9% dust-free.
  • BIO-ENZYMATIC FORMULA: Works to destroy tough litter box odors.
  • PREMIUM CLUMPING: Absorbs twice as much liquid as traditional clay litter.

Nature’s Miracle Premium Clumping Corn Cob Litter (10 Pounds) proves to be an excellent choice for environmentally conscious pet owners seeking a natural, effective solution for odor control. This litter is composed of real corn cob, which has been heat-processed, resulting in 99.9% dust-free granules. For ideal use, fill the litter box with 3-4 inches of litter, ensuring efficient absorption, which is twice that of traditional clay litters. Scoop daily, replacing litter when saturated, typically every two weeks. Note the benefits of its bio-enzymatic formula—specifically designed to eliminate odors—while adhering to proper usage instructions for a clean and pleasant environment.

Best For: Environmentally conscious pet owners looking for a natural and effective litter solution that controls odors.

Pros:

  • 99.9% dust-free, reducing respiratory issues for both pets and owners.
  • Absorbs twice as much liquid compared to traditional clay litters, ensuring a cleaner litter box.
  • Bio-enzymatic formula effectively eliminates odors while providing a pleasant scent.

Cons:

  • The lightweight nature of the litter can lead to tracking outside the box.
  • Clumping may break apart if not scooped gently, potentially making cleanup more difficult.
  • Users have reported price fluctuations, which can affect purchasing decisions.

Cats Pride Antibacterial Cat Litter (12 Pounds)

Cat's Pride Antibacterial Cat Litter: Destroys 99.9% of Odor-Causing Bacteria - Powerful Odor...
  • INCLUDES: (1) 12lb Jug of Antibacterial Scented Litter that destroys 99.9% of odor-causing bacteria and prevents bacterial odor
  • 40% LIGHTER: Compared to other traditional scoopable litters, making it easier to carry, pour, and store
  • ANTIBACTERIAL: Our formulation kills 99.9% of odor-causing bacteria and prevents bacterial odor for a clean litter box and sanitary home

Cats Pride Antibacterial Cat Litter (12 Pounds) offers a unique solution for cat owners who prioritize odor control and cleanliness, as it effectively destroys 99.9% of odor-causing bacteria. This litter is the only antibacterial clumping litter available in the U.S., making it a remarkable choice. Its innovative odor control system absorbs liquids, maintaining a clean litter box. Weighing 12 pounds, it’s 40% lighter than conventional options, facilitating easier handling. To use, pour to a depth of 3-4 inches, scoop daily, and clean the box each month. With a 30-day satisfaction guarantee, it’s an effective, reliable choice for your feline’s needs.

Best For: Cat owners who are looking for effective odor control and antibacterial protection in their litter.

Pros:

  • Destroys 99.9% of odor-causing bacteria, ensuring a cleaner environment for both cats and owners.
  • Lightweight design makes it easier to handle and clean compared to traditional litter.
  • 30-day satisfaction guarantee allows customers to try the product with minimal risk.

Cons:

  • Some users may find the price higher compared to standard cat litter options.
  • Limited availability in some regions due to being an exclusive antibacterial product.
  • May not clump as effectively for some users as other clumping litters on the market.

Sustainably Yours Cat Litter, Large-Grain Formula 10 lbs

Sustainably Yours Natural Cat Litter, Large-Grain Formula, Low Tracking, Exceptional Clumping & Odor...
  • OUTSTANDING ODOR CONTROL: Our proprietary formula instantly traps urine odor and prevents its build-up. And we never use fragrance, so there are no artificial scents that...
  • EXCEPTIONAL CLUMPING: Because our litter is made exclusively from corn and cassava, it’s naturally rich in starches. This results in dry, fast-forming, and firm clumps...
  • VIRTUALLY NO DUST: Our proprietary machinery removes dust at key points in the production process, resulting in a litter that protects cats from possible respiratory...

If you prioritize an eco-friendly option for your pet’s bathroom needs, Sustainably Yours Cat Litter, Large-Grain Formula, weighing in at 10 lbs, becomes a remarkable choice. This litter employs a proprietary formula that instantly traps urine odors while preventing build-up, effectively eliminating the need for artificial fragrances. Crafted from corn and cassava, it boasts excellent clumping ability, forming dry, fast, firm clumps for easy scooping. Remarkably, its production methodology minimizes dust, thereby protecting your cat from respiratory issues and keeping your home clean. Regular scooping and complete litter changes are recommended to maintain ideal hygiene and performance.

Best For: Eco-conscious pet owners looking for a natural, effective cat litter solution.

Pros:

  • Proprietary formula traps odors instantly without artificial fragrances.
  • Excellent clumping ability makes scooping easy and efficient.
  • Minimal dust production protects both cats’ respiratory health and home cleanliness.

Cons:

  • May be more expensive than traditional clay litters.
  • Some cats may require time to adjust to the texture.
  • Availability may vary by location, making it harder to find.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Cat Litter Alternatives

choosing safe cat litter

When choosing a cat litter alternative, you must consider several critical factors, including environmental impact, effectiveness in odor control, and clumping ability. Additionally, assess material safety standards and levels of dust and allergens to guarantee a healthy living environment for both you and your cat. Each element plays a significant role in determining the suitability of the litter for your specific needs and preferences.

Environmental Impact Considerations

Selecting cat litter alternatives based on their environmental impact can greatly influence your household’s sustainability efforts. When considering options, choose biodegradable litters made from renewable resources, such as wheat, corn, or recycled paper, which decompose more efficiently than traditional clay litters, taking years to break down. Evaluate the energy and water consumption involved in production; natural litters often require less compared to conventional options. Opt for non-toxic, chemical-free varieties that minimize health risks for both pets and humans. When you select products that prioritize sustainability, you actively participate in reducing landfill waste and combating climate change while providing safe and comfortable alternatives for your pets. Making informed choices creates a significant positive impact on the environment.

Odor Control Effectiveness

Effective odor control is vital for maintaining a pleasant living environment, as odors from cat waste can quickly permeate your home. When choosing a litter alternative, consider options made from natural ingredients like wheat, corn, or paper, which often outperform traditional clay litters in neutralizing ammonia and other odors. These biodegradable options utilize natural enzymes or absorbent properties, quickly eliminating unpleasant smells. Additionally, opt for dust-free formulations to greatly reduce airborne particles that can contribute to respiratory issues and unpleasant odors. Regular maintenance is essential; scoop daily and replace litter completely at least once a week. Implementing these practices will enhance your home’s air quality and prolong the freshness of your chosen cat litter alternative.

Clumping Ability Assessment

Evaluating the clumping ability of cat litter alternatives involves examining various factors that influence ease of use and cleanliness. Look for litters that form solid clumps that remain intact during scooping; this reduces the necessity for full litter changes, making maintenance simpler. Materials with finer granules typically offer superior clumping performance compared to larger granules, enhancing waste removal. Assess how quickly and firmly the litter clumps for both urine and solid waste, as performance can vary widely between types like wood, corn, and recycled paper. High-clumping litters effectively manage odors by encapsulating waste and minimizing air exposure, which is crucial for maintaining a hygienic litter box environment. Prioritize these aspects to choose the best litter alternative for your needs.

Material Safety Standards

When evaluating cat litter alternatives, material safety standards play an essential role in ensuring both your pet’s health and your own. Focus on products that are free from harmful substances, such as toxic chemicals and artificial fragrances, which can negatively impact health. Seek litters that comply with health safety regulations, having undergone rigorous testing for irritants and allergens. This is especially important for those with respiratory issues. Consider biodegradable and compostable options, as they not only benefit the environment but also contribute to safer waste management. Thoroughly sourced materials, particularly those from renewable resources, enhance safety. By prioritizing these criteria, you can make informed decisions that protect both your animal and yourself while promoting a greener home.

Dust and Allergens Levels

Dust and allergens in cat litter are critical considerations that can greatly affect indoor air quality and the well-being of both pets and their owners. High dust levels can exacerbate respiratory issues, including allergies and asthma. As a result, you should seek hypoallergenic litter options or those that claim to be 99% dust-free, as these formulations considerably reduce airborne allergens. Choosing natural materials like wheat or paper can additionally lower dust production compared to traditional clay litters. It’s essential to regularly scoop and replace the litter, which helps minimize allergen accumulation. Implementing a low-dust alternative enhances your home’s environment, making it healthier for you and your pet, while reducing maintenance time and effort around the litter box.

Cost and Value Comparison

How do you assess the cost-effectiveness of various cat litter alternatives? Begin by examining the cost per pound, noting that conventional clay litters typically cost less than eco-friendly options, which may be pricier due to superior materials. Evaluate the longevity of premium litters, as some offer excellent clumping and odor control, ultimately lowering overall expenses by decreasing the frequency of litter changes. Although biodegradable litters have higher initial costs, they appeal to environmentally conscious users and potentially provide savings through composting. Consider options with high dust-free ratings, which can minimize respiratory issues, possibly reducing veterinary costs. User feedback shows that premium litters, despite higher upfront expenses, often result in a better overall value through enhanced performance and user experience.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are These Cat Litter Alternatives Safe for My Pet’s Health?

Yes, many cat litter alternatives are safe for your pet’s health. Research shows that products made from natural ingredients, such as corn or wheat, minimize toxic exposure. Always check labels for known irritants, like fragrances or chemical additives, and consider your cat’s specific sensitivities. Guarantee litter is dust-free to reduce respiratory issues, and observe your cat’s behavior for any signs of discomfort or allergy after introducing a new product.

How Do I Transition My Cat to a New Litter Type?

To shift your cat to a new litter type, start by gradually mixing the new litter with the old litter in a 1:4 ratio, increasing the new litter’s proportion over a week. Monitor your cat’s behavior; if they resist, reduce the new litter’s quantity. During this period, maintain consistent litter box placement and cleanliness, as changes can cause stress. Observe for any discomfort in elimination; consult a veterinarian if issues arise.

Can These Alternatives Help With Odor Control?

Yes, many alternatives can effectively control odor, provided you follow specific guidelines. For example, cedar shavings possess natural antibacterial properties that reduce ammonia smell. In addition, products like corn or wheat-based litter absorb moisture efficiently, minimizing odor buildup. To enhance effectiveness, periodically clean the litter box, at least once a week, and replace litter fully every month. By monitoring your cat’s waste and adjusting litter types based on your observations, you’ll optimize odor control effectively.

What Is the Environmental Impact of These Litter Options?

The environmental impact of various litter options can be significant, depending on their composition and disposal methods. For example, clay-based litters often originate from strip mining, while biodegradable alternatives, like corn or wheat, might require less energy and produce fewer emissions. If you choose a litter made from recycled paper, it reduces deforestation. Always consider the end-of-life scenario; composting biodegradable litter appropriately can minimize landfill contributions and enhance soil quality in gardens.

For young kittens, consider specific brands like World’s Best Cat Litter, which uses whole-kernel corn; it’s 99% dust-free and biodegradable. Other options include PetSafe ScoopFree, offering crystal litter that absorbs moisture effectively. When selecting, make sure the litter is unscented to avoid respiratory irritation, maintaining a clean and safe environment. Additionally, be attentive to your kitten’s preferences, as familiarity with litter types promotes consistent usage. Monitor their behavior for any reactions during trials.